The Budget Trick the G.O.P. Might Use to Make a $4 Trillion Tax Cut Look Free A maneuver so wonky that it might be best explained with sports cars and anime streaming.
How much does a tax cut cost? It depends what you compare it to.
Republicans in Congress trying to advance a giant bill that includes $4 trillion in tax cut extensions are considering a novel strategy that would make the extension appear to be free. The trick: budgeting with the assumption that current policies extend indefinitely into the future — even those with an expiration date, like the 2017 tax cuts set to end next year. It’s the difference between making the extension appear to cost $4 trillion or zero.
Using this “current policy baseline” wouldn’t change the bill’s real effect on deficits or debt. But it would make it easier to actually make the tax cuts lasting by sidestepping a rule governing budget reconciliation, the process Republicans are using to pass the bill.
Yes, this sounds technical! That’s why we’ve enlisted some of Washington’s top budget veterans to explain this maneuver using a metaphor. Across the ideological spectrum, nearly all of the more than 20 experts we heard from disliked changing the baseline. Here are some of their examples:
“If budget reconciliation is like taking the express lanes on a highway (there’s extra rules and tolls, limited stops, but it gets you to where you want to go faster), using a current policy baseline for taxes is like slapping a fake license plate on your car. ” Zach Moller Director of the economic program at Third Way, which describes itself as a “center-left” research group; former Senate Budget Committee staffer
“It’s like taking an expensive week-long vacation and then assuming you can spend an extra $1,000 per day forever since you are no longer staying at the Plaza.” Marc Goldwein Senior vice president and senior policy director for the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, a nonpartisan group that tends to be hawkish on deficits; former government budget analyst
“Last year, despite being deeply in debt, I bought a $100,000 sports car. So next year, buying another $100,000 car is not irresponsible because I am merely spending the same amount of money as the year before. And if I purchase “only” a $70,000 car, then I should be congratulated for reducing my annual spending by $30,000.” Jessica Riedl Senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a conservative research group; chief economist for the former Republican senator Rob Portman of Ohio
“Your daughter is graduating from college. You have been paying for her education, so you are expecting to have a big improvement in your budget. However, after graduation, your daughter announces that there’s no need for her to go find a job, since covering her expenses is just a continuation of the ‘current policy.’” Michael Peterson Chairman and chief executive of the Peter G. Peterson Foundation, a nonpartisan research group that promotes deficit reduction
“It’s like getting an F on an assignment, but then the teacher applies a curve so the grade written on your paper might say you passed, but you still did poorly on the assignment.” Erica York Vice president of federal tax policy at Tax Foundation, a research center that generally favors lower taxes
“A current policy approach is like if you signed up for a Crunchyroll anime subscription that you knew you couldn’t afford, but now that it’s time to re-up the subscription, you pretend it’s free because you’ve already been paying it.” Bobby Kogan Senior director of federal budget policy at the Center for American Progress, a progressive research group; former adviser to the director of the Office of Management and Budget; former Senate Budget Committee staffer
“It’s like winning $50 at a poker table today and saying you’re ‘up’ without acknowledging that you lost $500 each of the previous 5 days.” Doug Criscitello Program integrity fellow at Arnold Ventures, a research and advocacy group; former executive director of the Golub Center for Finance and Policy at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology
“Your spouse decides that they’re willing to spend $900 for three months of an Equinox gym membership so they can get in shape. But when the three months ends, they tell you that continuing the gym membership is free since you’ve already been spending $300 a month.” Brendan Duke Senior director for federal budget policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a progressive research center; former senior policy adviser at the National Economic Council under President Biden
“Current policy is like being born on third base and thinking you hit a triple. ” Jim Kessler Executive vice president for policy and co-founder of Third Way; former legislative and policy director to Senator Chuck Schumer, Democrat of New York
Pretending $4 trillion in tax cuts will cost nothing may not be easy. Many Republican lawmakers who are concerned about the deficit are well aware that the bill will increase the deficit by a lot.
And the Senate parliamentarian, who advises legislators on the chamber’s rules, could rule that the current policy baseline isn’t allowed. Overruling or replacing the parliamentarian, while possible, is very rarely done. Doing so might make lawmakers less willing to follow Senate rules in the future.
But that doesn’t mean they won’t try. Influential Republican lawmakers, including Speaker Mike Johnson and Senator Mike Crapo, chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, have publicly endorsed the current policy baseline. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has said the Trump administration also favors the approach.
The choice is appealing not just for appearances. It also helps Republicans deal with an important procedural issue.
Republicans are trying to enact their tax and spending bill through a special process known as budget reconciliation — a way to get around a possible Senate filibuster and pass the bill with only Republican votes. That process comes with lots of its own rules. A big one is that the legislation can’t increase the deficit after the first 10 years. Using a current policy baseline could help a permanent tax cut — one with no expiration date — pass that test. With a current law baseline, Republicans would be stuck passing either another temporary tax cut or trying to find Democrats to vote for their bill, an unlikely prospect.
And that’s why they may be willing to overlook the judgments of most budget nerds and pretend they still live at the Plaza.
Current Policy Baseline: The Budget Trick That Could Make Tax Cuts Look Free
- Advertisment - 
Recent Comments
on 2023 NFL All-Rookie Team: CBS Sports draft expert, former GM unveil league’s best first-year players
on Boston College vs. Army live stream, how to watch online, CBS Sports Network channel finder, odds
on Disgraced sports doctor Larry Nassar stabbed multiple times at Florida federal prison: AP sources
on Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning Shot Tom Cruise’s Bike Stunt Before Knowing The Reason For It
on “Completely Tormented”: How Tom Cruise Was Almost Cast In The Shawshank Redemption (& Why He Wasn’t)
on 2022-23 CBS Sports All-America teams: College basketball’s best, most talented and valuable players
on Abdominal tears and unvaccinated travel are among the many questions for tennis ahead of the US Open
on A weaker dollar, skyrocketing prices and ‘record’ visitor numbers: Good luck in Europe this summer
on Senate Democrats plan to subpoena Harlan Crow and Leonard Leo over Supreme Court justices’ travel
on Kim Kardashian Fans Call Her Out for Annoying Behavior at LA Lakers Game With 8-Year-Old Son Saint
on Dave Portnoy: Taylor Swift’s security should ‘drag Kim Kardashian to jail’ if she attends Eras Tour
on Ford Blue Cruise: US regulators investigate fatal crashes involving hands-free driving technology
on Arsenal highlighted for spending 26 seconds taking corner v Everton – Sky Sports’ tweet backfires
on ACC football schedule: League approves 3-5-5 format with all teams in one division starting in 2023
on Get ready for a SpongeBob and slime Super Bowl: CBS and Nickelodeon team up for NFL’s biggest game
on Devout athletes find strength in their faith. But practicing it and elite sports can pose hurdles
on “Completely Tormented”: How Tom Cruise Was Almost Cast In The Shawshank Redemption (& Why He Wasn’t)
on A bearish options trade that pays off if hotel stocks start to feel a travel slowdown like airlines
on Air Force vs. San Diego State live stream, channel, prediction, how to watch on CBS Sports Network
on Ford Blue Cruise: US regulators investigate fatal crashes involving hands-free driving technology
on Dallas Cowboys Will “Bring You Nothing But Bad Luck”, Sports Media Vet Warns Luka Doncic’s Mavericks
on 2024 College World Series: Jac Caglianone keeps Gators alive with homer despite short pitching start
on Arsenal highlighted for spending 26 seconds taking corner v Everton – Sky Sports’ tweet backfires
on 2024 Super Bowl: CBS Sports Network and CBS Sports HQ to combine for 115 hours of weeklong coverage
on ‘I Will Immediately Retire From Boxing and Fight Jorge Masvidal…’: Jake Paul Starts 2023 With a Bang
on Mission: Impossible review: The new version makes it clear what these movies have always been about
on Ford Blue Cruise: US regulators investigate fatal crashes involving hands-free driving technology
on Iowa State starting RB Jirehl Brock among latest college football players charged in gambling probe
on Cruise worker accused of stabbing woman and 2 security guards with scissors on ship headed to Alaska
on If you’re a frequent traveler, these wrap tops from Aday will revolutionize your on-the-go wardrobe
on “Completely Knocked Me Out”: Rob Lowe Recalls Boxing Match With Tom Cruise On 1983 Brat Pack Classic
on Army vs. Coastal Carolina live stream, how to watch online, CBS Sports Network channel finder, odds
on As more abortion bans occur, many patients must travel hundreds of miles for care – or be stranded
on ‘1000-Lb. Sisters’ Tammy Slaton Is Still ‘Too Large’ to Fly in a Plane Despite All the Weight Loss
on CA couple forced to take 8-hour train ride home amid Southwest fiasco: ‘We just want to get home’
on Inside Floyd Mayweather’s Lavish Lifestyle: A Look at His Stunning Car Collection and Private Jet
on Disney Cruise Line Creating New Display on Castaway Cay Honoring Families Who Have Sailed 50+ Times
on College sports giants struggle to get a bailout from Congress as athletes push for employee status
on Johnny Knoxville Talks Jackass Stunts And How They Compare To Tom Cruise’s Mission: Impossible Work
on Napoli owner admits he ‘knew’ Victor Osimhen would end up at ‘Real Madrid, PSG or one English club’
on Lake Tahoe officials tackle overtourism with focus on management, not marketing; new fees may loom
on Massive $1,260,000,000 News Strikes Wrexham’s New League Days After Ryan Reynolds’ Side’s Promotion
on Florida athletic board bans transgender volleyball player from HS sports for a year, school fined
on Daniel Cormier joins the Louisiana Sports Hall of Fame Class of 2024 alongside NFL legend Drew Brees
on Camilla Parker Bowles Revealed the ‘Nicest Thing’ She and Prince Charles Do When They Travel Is Free
on Ford Blue Cruise: US regulators investigate fatal crashes involving hands-free driving technology
on Carlos Sainz’s Soccer Fanboy Emerges as Spaniard Shares Defining Moment With This Real Madrid Legend
on Arsenal highlighted for spending 26 seconds taking corner v Everton – Sky Sports’ tweet backfires
on Inside the Michael Jordan ‘Air’ movie, plus why NFL, others are buying into the sports film industry
on As more abortion bans occur, many patients must travel hundreds of miles for care – or be stranded
on David and Victoria Beckham so ‘Charmed’ by Tom Cruise They Have His Photos on Display at Their Home
on Napoli owner admits he ‘knew’ Victor Osimhen would end up at ‘Real Madrid, PSG or one English club’
on Erdogan to attend Turkey-Netherlands Euro 2024 quarterfinal amid diplomatic row with host Germany
on Camilla Parker Bowles Revealed the ‘Nicest Thing’ She and Prince Charles Do When They Travel Is Free
on Ford Blue Cruise: US regulators investigate fatal crashes involving hands-free driving technology
on Gymnastics GOAT Simone Biles Poses With the First American Woman to Land Highly Distinguished Job
on NASA and SpaceX Crew-6 Mission: Experiments Could Reveal Extraterrestrial Travel’s Health Impacts
on Arsenal highlighted for spending 26 seconds taking corner v Everton – Sky Sports’ tweet backfires
on Britney Spears And Sam Asghari Both Seen Without Wedding Rings As Singer Vacations With Her Manager
on Southwest Airlines made $683 million in Q2, as a hectic summer travel season led to record revenue
on Georgia Senate passes sports betting bill, but odds dim with as constitutional amendment required
on Arsenal highlighted for spending 26 seconds taking corner v Everton – Sky Sports’ tweet backfires
on Devout athletes find strength in their faith. But practicing it and elite sports can pose hurdles
on Exercise Scientist Reveals an Unlikely Benefit of Using Creatine: “Many People Did Not See Coming”
on Southwest Airlines made $683 million in Q2, as a hectic summer travel season led to record revenue
on Hollywood Reporter: Tom Cruise negotiated with movie studios over AI before the actors strike began
on A weaker dollar, skyrocketing prices and ‘record’ visitor numbers: Good luck in Europe this summer
on “Completely Knocked Me Out”: Rob Lowe Recalls Boxing Match With Tom Cruise On 1983 Brat Pack Classic
on Joe Manchin and Tommy Tuberville introduce bill on name, image and likeness rules for college sports
on 2023 NBA playoffs: Scores, results, series schedules, times as Clippers steal Game 1, Nuggets cruise
on How Does Jack Nicklaus Travel? Exploring the Private Jets Owned by the ‘Golden Bear’ Over the Years
on Katherine Paprocka allegedly embezzled nearly $600k from school for family vacations, IVF treatment
on Napoli owner admits he ‘knew’ Victor Osimhen would end up at ‘Real Madrid, PSG or one English club’
on Not to be missed on Netflix is a romantic and light film that will make you travel through time
on Camilla Parker Bowles Revealed the ‘Nicest Thing’ She and Prince Charles Do When They Travel Is Free
on Mad Dog’s
on Angel Reese Launches Foundation Dedicated To Empowering Women Through Sports & Financial Literacy
on Billionaire Vince McMahon Once Spent a Whopping Amount of $175,000 For Brock Lesnar’s Convenience
on Joe Manchin and Tommy Tuberville introduce bill on name, image and likeness rules for college sports
on Cruise guest gets stuck on ‘claustrophobic’ water slide suspended over ocean: ‘That is super scary’
on Dave Portnoy: Taylor Swift’s security should ‘drag Kim Kardashian to jail’ if she attends Eras Tour
on EXCLUSIVE: Former KBM Crew Chief Makes Revelations About Kyle Busch but Keeps Hush About KBM Sale
on College basketball rankings: Virginia joins preseason Top 25 And 1, ready to contend for ACC title
on Drawing Comparisons to Stephen Curry, Stephen A. Smith Lauds Caitlin Clark for Achieving a Rare Feat
on CBS Sports, Serie A announce new TV rights deal; Paramount+ to air over 400 Italian soccer matches
on Inside Floyd Mayweather’s Lavish Lifestyle: A Look at His Stunning Car Collection and Private Jet
on A bearish options trade that pays off if hotel stocks start to feel a travel slowdown like airlines
on Johnny Knoxville Talks Jackass Stunts And How They Compare To Tom Cruise’s Mission: Impossible Work
on Braun Strowman Reportedly Set for WWE Return Abroad on Promotional Tour After 6 Months Out Injured
on Lake Tahoe officials tackle overtourism with focus on management, not marketing; new fees may loom
on Napoli owner admits he ‘knew’ Victor Osimhen would end up at ‘Real Madrid, PSG or one English club’
on CBS Sports, Serie A announce new TV rights deal; Paramount+ to air over 400 Italian soccer matches
on Camilla Parker Bowles Revealed the ‘Nicest Thing’ She and Prince Charles Do When They Travel Is Free
on Cruise guest gets stuck on ‘claustrophobic’ water slide suspended over ocean: ‘That is super scary’
on Devout athletes find strength in their faith. But practicing it and elite sports can pose hurdles
on ‘Pokémon Scarlet’ and ‘Violet’ Fan Theories Suggest Legendary Time Travel, Alternate Dimension Plot
on Cruise worker accused of stabbing woman and 2 security guards with scissors on ship headed to Alaska
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on Johnny Knoxville Talks Jackass Stunts And How They Compare To Tom Cruise’s Mission: Impossible Work
on Napoli owner admits he ‘knew’ Victor Osimhen would end up at ‘Real Madrid, PSG or one English club’
on Camilla Parker Bowles Revealed the ‘Nicest Thing’ She and Prince Charles Do When They Travel Is Free
on CBS Sports, Serie A announce new TV rights deal; Paramount+ to air over 400 Italian soccer matches
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on ‘1000-Lb. Sisters’ Tammy Slaton Is Still ‘Too Large’ to Fly in a Plane Despite All the Weight Loss
on Cruise worker accused of stabbing woman and 2 security guards with scissors on ship headed to Alaska
on ‘1000-Lb. Sisters’ Tammy Slaton Is Still ‘Too Large’ to Fly in a Plane Despite All the Weight Loss
on Johnny Knoxville Talks Jackass Stunts And How They Compare To Tom Cruise’s Mission: Impossible Work
on Napoli owner admits he ‘knew’ Victor Osimhen would end up at ‘Real Madrid, PSG or one English club’
on Quite Possibly The Most Elite Travel Credit Card One Can Have: What On Earth Is The Amex Centurion?
on Camilla Parker Bowles Revealed the ‘Nicest Thing’ She and Prince Charles Do When They Travel Is Free
on ‘1000-Lb. Sisters’ Tammy Slaton Is Still ‘Too Large’ to Fly in a Plane Despite All the Weight Loss
on Quite Possibly The Most Elite Travel Credit Card One Can Have: What On Earth Is The Amex Centurion?
on ‘1000-Lb. Sisters’ Tammy Slaton Is Still ‘Too Large’ to Fly in a Plane Despite All the Weight Loss
on Quite Possibly The Most Elite Travel Credit Card One Can Have: What On Earth Is The Amex Centurion?
on Camilla Parker Bowles Revealed the ‘Nicest Thing’ She and Prince Charles Do When They Travel Is Free
on ‘1000-Lb. Sisters’ Tammy Slaton Is Still ‘Too Large’ to Fly in a Plane Despite All the Weight Loss
on Dead Reckoning, a video shows the behind the scenes of the incredible upcoming film SparkChronicles
on Dallas Cowboys Will “Bring You Nothing But Bad Luck”, Sports Media Vet Warns Luka Doncic’s Mavericks
on ‘1000-Lb. Sisters’ Tammy Slaton Is Still ‘Too Large’ to Fly in a Plane Despite All the Weight Loss
on Lake Tahoe officials tackle overtourism with focus on management, not marketing; new fees may loom
on Erdogan to attend Turkey-Netherlands Euro 2024 quarterfinal amid diplomatic row with host Germany
on College sports giants struggle to get a bailout from Congress as athletes push for employee status
on Bryan’s Breakdown: Tracking high-impact winter storm late this week; bitter cold Christmas weekend
on Johnny Knoxville Talks Jackass Stunts And How They Compare To Tom Cruise’s Mission: Impossible Work
on Napoli owner admits he ‘knew’ Victor Osimhen would end up at ‘Real Madrid, PSG or one English club’
on Camilla Parker Bowles Revealed the ‘Nicest Thing’ She and Prince Charles Do When They Travel Is Free
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on Gravitas Ventures Acquires North American Rights To Distribute Julia Camara Thriller ‘Stronghold ’
on 2024 College World Series: Jac Caglianone keeps Gators alive with homer despite short pitching start
on College basketball rankings: Kansas helps Big 12 lead conference race for most Top 100 And 1 players
on Ahead of big sports weekend, dispute with Disney leaves millions of cable subscribers in the dark
on ‘1000-Lb. Sisters’ Tammy Slaton Is Still ‘Too Large’ to Fly in a Plane Despite All the Weight Loss
on Boise State vs. Air Force live stream, odds, channel, prediction, how to watch on CBS Sports Network
on 2022 LIV Golf in Jeddah: Schedule, field of players, prize money, purse, live stream, watch online
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on Erdogan to attend Turkey-Netherlands Euro 2024 quarterfinal amid diplomatic row with host Germany
on Ahead of big sports weekend, dispute with Disney leaves millions of cable subscribers in the dark
on A missile fired by Houthis strikes a US-owned vessel off Yemen in the Gulf of Aden, raising tensions
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on “Bro Is Jogging”: Resurfaced Video of Usain Bolt’s 9.84 Seconds Run, Leaves Sports World in Denial
on Dave Portnoy: Taylor Swift’s security should ‘drag Kim Kardashian to jail’ if she attends Eras Tour
on CBS Sports, Serie A announce new TV rights deal; Paramount+ to air over 400 Italian soccer matches
on LIVALL Showcases Smart Helmets For Cyclists And Commuters At Pepcom Holiday Shopping Preview Event
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on Mission: Impossible review: The new version makes it clear what these movies have always been about
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on Disgraced sports doctor Larry Nassar stabbed multiple times at Florida federal prison: AP sources
on Lake Tahoe officials tackle overtourism with focus on management, not marketing; new fees may loom
on Can Tom Cruise Save The Box Office Again With Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning? An Investigation
on How The Other Half Fly: VistaJet Goes To Enviable Lengths To Make Air Travel Better For Your Body
on Following Exchange With Caitlin Clark At News Conference, Columnist Won’t Cover Indiana Fever Games
on Lake Tahoe officials tackle overtourism with focus on management, not marketing; new fees may loom
on Air Force vs. Utah State live stream, how to watch online, CBS Sports Network channel finder, odds
on